Classic of Documents
周書 Zhōu shū
多士 第四十二 Book Forty-two · Duō shì
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
商民遷洛者,亦有有位之士,故周公洛邑初政,以王命總呼多士而告之,編書者因以名篇,亦誥體也。今文、古文皆有。○吳氏曰:「方遷商民于洛之時,成周未作,其後王與周公患四方之遠,鍳三監之叛,於是始作洛邑,欲徙周而居之。其曰『昔朕來自奄,大降爾四國民命,我乃明致天罰,移爾遐逖,比事臣我宗,多遜』者,述遷民之初也;曰『今朕作大邑于茲洛,予惟四方罔攸賓,亦惟爾多士攸服,奔走臣我,多遜』者,言遷民而後作洛也。故《洛誥》一篇,終始皆無欲遷商民之意,惟周公既誥成王留治于洛之後,乃曰『伻來毖殷』,又曰『王伻殷乃承敘』,當時商民已遷于洛,故其言如此。」愚謂武王已有都洛之志,故周公黜殷之後,以殷民反覆難制,即遷于洛,至是建成周,造廬舍,定疆場,乃告命與之更始焉爾。此《多士》之所以作也。由是而推,則《召誥》攻位之庶殷,其已遷洛之民歟?不然,則受都,今衛州也;洛邑,今西京也,相去四百餘里,召公安得舍近之友民,而役遠之讎民哉?《書序》以為「成周既成,遷殷頑民」者,謬矣,吾固以為非孔子所作也。
惟三月,周公初于新邑洛,用告商王士。
In the third month, at the commencement of the government of the duke of Chow in the new city of Lŏ, he announced the royal will to the officers of the Shang dynasty, saying,
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
此《多士》之本序也。三月,成王祀洛次年之三月也。周公至洛久矣,此言初者,成王既不果遷,留公治洛,至是公始行治洛之事,故謂之初也。曰商王士者,貴之也。
王若曰:「爾殷遺多士。弗弔!旻天大降喪于殷;我有周佑命,將天明威,致王罰,敕殷命終于帝。
“The king speaks to this effect:—‘Ye numerous officers who remain from the dynasty of Yin, great ruin came down on Yin from the want of pity in compassionate Heaven, and we, the princes of Chow, received its favouring decree. We accordingly felt charged with its bright terrors; carried out the punishments which kings inflict; rightly disposed of the appointment of Yin; and finished the work of God.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
弗弔,未詳,意其為歎憫之辭,當時方言爾也。旻天,秋天也,主肅殺而言。歎憫言旻天大降災害而喪殷,我周受眷佑之命,奉將天之明威,致王罰之公,敕正殷命而革之,以終上帝之事。蓋推革命之公,以開諭之也。
「肆爾多士,非我小國敢弋殷命,惟天不畀,允罔固亂,弼我。我其敢求位?
Now, ye numerous officers, it was not that our small country dared to aim at the appointment of Yin. But Heaven was not with Yin, for indeed it would not strengthen its misrule. It therefore helped us;—did we dare to seek the throne of ourselves?
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
肆,與《康誥》「肆汝小子封」同。弋,取也,弋鳥之弋,言有心於取之也。呼多士誥之,謂以勢而言,我小國亦豈敢弋取殷命?蓋栽者培之,傾者覆之,固其治而不固其亂者,天之道也。惟天不與殷,信其不固殷之亂矣。惟天不固殷之亂,故輔我周之治,而天位自有所不容辭者,我其敢有求位之心哉?
「惟帝不畀,惟我下民秉為,惟天明畏。
God was not for Yin, as appeared from the conduct of our inferior people, in which there is the brilliant dreadfulness of Heaven.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
秉,持也。言天命之所不與,即民心之所秉為;民心之所秉為,即天威之所明畏者也。反覆天民相因之理,以見天之果不外乎民,民之果不外乎天也。《詩》言「秉彝」,此言「秉為」者,彝以理言,為以用言也。
「我聞曰:上帝引逸。有夏不適逸,則惟帝降格,嚮于時夏。弗克庸帝,大淫泆,有辭。惟時天罔念聞,厥惟廢元命,降致罰。
‘I have heard the saying—“God leads men to tranquil security;” but the sovereign of Hea would not move to such security, whereupon God sent down corrections, indicating His mind to him. Këĕ, however, would not be warned by God, but proceeded to greater dissoluteness and sloth and excuses for himself. Then Heaven no longer regarded nor heard him, but disallowed his great appointment, and inflicted extreme punishment.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
引,導;逸,安也。降格,與《呂刑》「降格」同。呂氏曰:「上帝引逸者,非有形聲之接也。人心得其安,則亹亹而不能已,斯則上帝引之也。是理坦然,亦何閒于桀?第桀喪其良心,自不適於安耳。帝實引之,桀實避之,帝猶未遽絕也,乃降格災異,以示意嚮於桀。桀猶不知警懼,不能敬用帝命,乃大肆淫逸,雖有矯誣之辭,而天罔念聞之,仲虺所謂『帝用不臧』是也。廢其大命,降致其罰,而夏祚終矣。」
「乃命爾先祖成湯革夏,俊民甸四方。
Hereupon it charged your founder, T‘ang the Successful, to set Hea aside, and by means of able men to rule the empire.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
甸,治也。伊尹稱湯「旁求俊彥」,孟子稱湯「立賢無方」,蓋明揚俊民,分布遠邇,甸治區畫,成湯立政之大經也。周公反復以夏、商為言者,蓋夏之亡,即殷之亡;湯之興,即武王之興也。商民觀是,亦可以自反矣。
「自成湯至于帝乙,罔不明德恤祀。
From T‘ang the Successful down to the emperor Yih, every sovereign sought to make his virtue illustrious, and duly attended to the sacrifices.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
明德者,所以修其身;恤祀者,所以敬乎神也。
「亦惟天丕建,保乂有殷;殷王亦罔敢失帝,罔不配天其澤。
And thus it was that while Heaven exerted a great establishing influence, preserving and regulating the house of Yin, its sovereigns on their part were humbly careful not to lose the favour of God, and strove to manifest a good-doing corresponding to that of Heaven.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
亦惟天大建立,保治有殷,殷之先王亦皆操存此心,無敢失帝之則,無不配天以澤民也。
「在今後嗣王,誕罔顯于天,矧曰其有聽念于先王勤家?誕淫厥泆,罔顧于天顯民祗。
But in these times, their successor showed himself greatly ignorant of the ways of Heaven, and much less could it be expected of him that he would be regardful of the earnest labours of his fathers for the country. Greatly abandoned to dissolute idleness, he paid no regard to the bright principles of Heaven, nor the awfulness of the people.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
後嗣王,紂也。紂大不明於天道,況曰能聽念商先王之勤勞於邦家者乎?大肆淫佚,無復顧念天之顯道、民之敬畏者也。
「惟時上帝不保,降若茲大喪。
On this account God no longer protected him, but sent down the great ruin which we have witnessed.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
大喪者,國亡而身戮也。
「惟天不畀不明厥德;
Heaven was not with him because he did not seek to illustrate his virtue.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
商先王以明德,而天丕建,則商後王不明德,而天不畀矣。
「凡四方小大邦喪,罔非有辭于罰。」
Indeed, with regard to the overthrow of all States, great and small, throughout the four quarters of the empire, in every case there are reasons to be alleged for their punishment.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
凡四方小大邦國喪亡,其致罰皆有可言者,況商罪貫盈,而周奉辭以伐之者乎?
王若曰:「爾殷多士。今惟我周王丕靈承帝事。
“The king speaks to this effect:—‘Ye numerous officers of Yin, the case now is this, that the sovereigns of our Chow, from their great goodness were charged with the work of God.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
靈,善也。大善承天之所為也。《武成》言「祗承上帝,以遏亂略」是也。
「有命曰『割殷』,告敕于帝。
There was the charge to them, “Cut off Yin.” They proceeded to perform it, and announced the correcting work to God.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
帝有命曰「割殷」,則不得不戡定翦除,告其敕正之事于帝也。《武成》言「告于皇天后土」、「將有大正于商」者是也。
「惟我事不貳適,惟爾王家我適。
In our affairs we have followed no double aims:—ye of the royal house of Yin must follow us.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
「上帝臨汝,毋貳爾心」,惟我事不貳適之謂;「上帝既命,侯于周服」,惟爾王家我適之謂。言割殷之事,非有私心,一於從帝,而無貳適,則爾殷王家自不容不我適矣。周不貳於帝,殷其能貳於周乎?蓋示以確然不可動搖之意,而潛消頑民反側之情爾。然聖賢事不貳適,日用飲食,莫不皆然,蓋所以事天也,豈特割殷之事而已哉?
「予其曰:『惟爾洪無度;我不爾動,自乃邑。』
‘May I not say that you were very lawless? I did not want to remove you. The thing came from your own city.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
三監倡亂,予其曰:「乃汝大為非法,非我爾動,變自爾邑。」猶《伊訓》所謂「造攻自鳴條」也。
「予亦念天即于殷大戾,肆不正。」
When I consider also how Heaven has drawn near to Yin with so great tribulations, it must be that there was there what was not right.’”
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
予亦念天就殷邦,屢降大戾,紂既死,武庚又死,故邪慝不正,言當遷徙也。
王曰:「猷告爾多士。予惟時其遷居西爾。非我一人奉德不康寧,時惟天命,無違。朕不敢有後,無我怨。
“The king says, ‘Ho! I declare to you, ye numerous officers, it is simply on account of these things that I have removed and settled you in the west;—it was not that I, the one man, considered it a part of my virtue to make you untranquil. The thing was from the decree of Heaven; do not resist me; I dare not have any further change for you. Do not murmur against me.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
時,是也,指上文殷大戾而言。謂惟是之故,所以遷居西爾,非我一人樂如是之遷徙震動也,是惟天命如此,汝毋違越。我不敢有後命,謂有他罰,爾無我怨也。
「惟爾知,惟殷先人有冊有典,殷革夏命。
Ye know that your fathers of the Yin dynasty had their archives and narratives showing how Yin superseded the appointment of Hea.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
即其舊聞以開諭之也。殷之先世,有冊書典籍,載殷改夏命之事,正如是耳,爾何獨疑於今乎?
「今爾又曰:『夏迪簡在王庭,有服在百僚。』予一人惟聽用德,肆予敢求爾于天邑商。予惟率肆矜爾。非予罪,時惟天命。」
Ye now indeed say further, “The officers of Hea were chosen and promoted to the imperial court, or had their places among the mass of officers.” I, the one man, listen only to the virtuous and employ them; and it was with this view that I presumed to seek you out in your heavenly city of Shang. I thereby follow the ancient example, and have pity on you. Your present non-employment is no fault of mine; it is by the decree of Heaven.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
周公既舉商革夏事以諭頑民,頑民復以商革夏事責周,謂商革夏命之初,凡夏之士,皆啟迪簡拔,在商王之庭,有服列于百僚之間,今周於商士,未聞有所簡拔也。周公舉其言,以大義折之,言爾頑民雖有是言,然予一人所聽用者,惟以德而已,故予敢求爾於天邑商,而遷之於洛者,以冀率德改行焉。予惟循商故事,矜恤於爾而已,其不爾用者,非我之罪也,是惟天命如此。蓋章德者,天之命,今頑民滅德,而欲求用,得乎?
王曰:「多士。昔朕來自奄,予大降爾四國民命。我乃明致天罰,移爾遐逖,比事臣我宗,多遜。」
“The king says, ‘Ye numerous officers, formerly, when I came from Yen, I greatly mitigated the penalty in favour of the lives of the people of your four countries. At the same time I made evident the punishment appointed by Heaven, and removed you to this distant abode, that you might be near the ministers who had served in our honoured capital, and learn their much obedience.’”
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
降,猶今法降等云者。言昔我來自商奄之時,汝四國之民,罪皆應死,我大降爾命,不忍誅戮,乃止明致天罰,移爾遠居于洛,以親比臣我宗周,有多遜之美。其罰蓋亦甚輕,其恩固已甚厚,今乃有所怨望乎?詳此章,則商民之遷固已久矣。
王曰:「告爾殷多士。今予惟不爾殺,予惟時命有申。今朕作大邑于茲洛,予惟四方罔攸賓。亦惟爾多士攸服,奔走臣我,多遜。
“The king says, ‘I declare to you, ye numerous officers of Yin,—now I have not put you to death, and therefore I repeat to you my charge again. I have built this great city here in Lŏ, considering that there was no other place in which to receive my guests from the four quarters, and also that you, je numerous officers, might here with zealous activity, perform the part of ministers to us with much obedience.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
以自奄之命為初命,則此命為申命也。言我惟不忍爾殺,故申明此命。且我所以營洛者,以四方諸侯無所賓禮之地,亦惟爾等服事奔走,臣我多遜,而無所處故也。詳此章,則遷民在營洛之先矣。吳氏曰:「來自奄稱昔者,遠日之辭也;作大邑稱今者,近日之辭也。『移爾遐逖,比事臣我宗,多遜』者,期之之辭也;『攸服奔走,臣我多遜』者,果能之辭也。以此又知遷民在前,而作洛在後也。」
「爾乃尚有爾土,爾乃尚寧幹止。
You have still here I may say your grounds, and here you may still rest in your duties and dwellings.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
幹,事;止,居也。爾乃庶幾有爾田業,庶幾安爾所事,安爾所居也。詳此章所言,皆仍舊有土田居止之辭,信商民之遷舊矣。孔氏不得其說,而以得反所生釋之,於文義似矣,而事則非也。
「爾克敬,天惟畀矜爾;爾不克敬,爾不啻不有爾土,予亦致天之罰于爾躬。
If you can reverently obey, Heaven will favour and compassionate you. If you cannot reverently obey, you will not only not have your lands, but I will also carry to the utmost Heaven’s inflictions on your persons.
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
敬則言動無不循理,天之所福,吉祥所集也;不敬則言動莫不違悖,天之所禍,刑戮所加也,豈特竄徙不有爾土而已哉?身亦有所不能保矣。
「今爾惟時宅爾邑,繼爾居,爾厥有幹有年于茲洛,爾小子乃興,從爾遷。」
Now you may here dwell in your villages, and perpetuate your families; you may pursue your occupations and enjoy your years in this Lŏ; your children also will prosper:—all from your being removed here.’”
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
邑,「四井為邑」之邑。繼者,承續安居之謂。有營為,有壽考,皆于茲洛焉。爾之子孫乃興,自爾遷始也。夫自亡國之末裔,為起家之始祖,頑民雖愚,亦知所擇矣。
王曰:「又曰,時予乃或言,爾攸居。」
“The king says,—; and again he says, ‘Whatsoever I have spoken, is all on account of my anxiety about your residence here.’”
注 Cai Chen 書集傳
「王曰」之下,當有闕文,以《多方》篇末「王曰」、「又曰」推之可見。時我或有所言,皆以爾之所居止為念也。申結上文爾居之意。